Gowner
Review Showcase
106 Hours played
When I play games, what I want is a good story. When I play an RPG, what I want is the freedom to choose how that story goes through my own actions and words. Two ingredients for a simple recipe.

The Outer Worlds 1 was incredibly disappointing on both counts. I can't even remember what the story was about but I do still remember the feeling I had many times while playing it where I expected Obsidian to have thought of an obvious way to do a quest or to access an area but was disappointed when there was just nothing.

Unfortunately, the same is true again. In a depressing parallel to Cyberpunk 2077, there is one quest in the very beginning that allows you tons of choice and lots of freedom, and then as you continue, you can tell the game is *pretending* that more quests are the same but once you actually test boundaries, you just get funneled into the one way the quest was supposed to go.

For example (mild spoilers), one quest in the companion quest for Marisol has you travel to a place where you know a dangerous experiment is being conducted. The quest tells you that you need to sneakily go into the experiment machinery and make very slight errors, such that the experiment fails without being suspicious. You go down into the 4 rooms where you have to do specific things for the sabotage and in each room, there are instructions by the scientists on how to work the machines perfectly so the experiment succeeds.

My expectation was that I would be allowed to simply send things off in the correct way and cause the experiment to go through anyway because, you know, it's an RPG. Two of the rooms allowed me to do this. The other two forced me through game mechanics to sabotage the experiment anyway, even though my character and I didn't want to do this.

Later in the same quest, you are tasked with making the woman in charge forget about the science, so she never attempts the experiment again. It is made clear that there are two avenues for you:
1. Use a good argument to scramble her brain or something like that (it doesn't make much sense)
2. Sabotage her room and cause her to die but without raising suspicion
My character was a loose cannon, someone who preferred murder over complicated logic, so I saved the game, went downstairs and killed every single person in the entire base. Nobody was left alive except the woman in charge upstairs. Naturally, I expected her to go "what have you done" or something and me be able to intimidate her "if you try again, I'll find you again blah blah," or to go in and kill her and call it a job well done, or to convince her that science is evil and she joins my crew... whatever. But no. If you go downstairs and you kill someone, the quest immediately ends and is considered "botched." If you kill everyone and go back up to the woman, she just says "well you chose badly, get the ♥♥♥♥ out of here" and you cannot do ANYTHING AT ALL except leave. The quest is just done.

So I reload, I do everything the "right" way, I sabotage the experiment, I sabotage the woman's room so she dies "of an accident" and it's all well and good. We take the elevator down and are confronted by someone who works at the base. And I kid you not, one of the dialogue option is to NOW just kill them all. I choose it and we kill them all, again, just like I did before. But this time, the quest succeeds. So, killing everyone BEFORE you kill the woman in charge is bad. You fail. Killing everyone AFTER the woman in charge is dead is good. You succeed. Make sense? No? Not to me either.

And the entire game is like this. Almost every quest is a linear story with very very very minor points of decision. In New Vegas, you were able to kill everyone and anyone without immersion being broken. In this game, you can, too, but only to a certain point before a faction goes "well you're so bad we'll shoot you on sight" and the game pops up a banner saying "buddy, you ♥♥♥♥♥♥ up, you should load a save game or the game will suck now."

The writing also just seems uninspired to me. There's really not that much to say about it. There are three factions in the game. Evil imperialists, evil corporatists and evil scientists. You yourself are from the Earth Directorate (which sounds way too similar to The Protectorate) but that itself is not represented as a faction in the game. There's a bad experiment that creates bad space rifts that want to destroy the whole universe which, you guessed it, is bad. So, you have to close the rifts, so that the bad thing doesn't happen. Does that sound interesting to you?

At some point you pick up a tool that lets you manipulate the rifts. The game can't decide if the tool opens or closes the rift or if it reverses time. Characters say all three interchangeably. But the only effect that this has is either
1. you can collect a resource from the rift
2. some platforms fly out of the rift so you can do a timed platforming challenge
Does this sound interesting to you?

This is mostly subjective but I just find it hard to believe that every single person in this entire solar system talks like a 32 year old Redditor. Every character is at all times only one wrong turn away from devolving into full on Shakespearean diction. Nobody has ever or will ever speak the way people in this game speak. Also, as a great big fan of math and a sort of mathematician myself, it just gets on my ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ nerves that the Order members keep using math-related terms in completely nonsensical puns. I appreciate a good pun, but all of the math puns in this game were written by someone who doesn't know what the words mean and if you know a little math, you'll notice that, too. I heard a woman say "don't let me go on a cotangent." Get it? Get it?

The problem with that is that it takes you out of the world. This is supposed to be a cult of extremely advanced scientists and mathematicians who are working on -- and this is real -- the universal theory. But they keep calling it an equation because, again, the people who wrote this don't know what they're talking about. Science and math are purely aesthetic in this game. 0 effort at all was taken to actually arrive at a world informed by the existence of a math cult. Instead, it's just a regular religiously fanatic cult stereotype but replace "god" with "math" and "prophecy" with "mathematical prediction." You want Anathem, but unfortunately, all you're getting is The Outer Worlds 2. Again, this is very subjective because I happen to be an unwashed nerd who cares about this stuff.


What about the gameplay? I don't much care and I'm not a good judge of it, but most of it, I liked. The shooting feels good and, at least on story difficulty, combat feels nice to me. I cause punchy impacts, the bullet time is satisfying and the perks, flaws and mods for your equipment allow you to minmax really well. I expect a million "can you beat TOW2 with only..." videos soon. What I didn't like here was the level design. Sometimes, it was infuriatingly counter-intuitive. And thanks to the truly, actually horrible map, you will get stuck or lost regularly. There are also SO MANY bottomless pits in the game that you will jump into by accident.

Bugs (not many but some really bad, also spoilers):
- After clearing an area, enemy sounds will continue being there as if enemies were alive
- If you kill Zebulon while Niles is not with you, the confrontation cutscene is completely bugged. Niles doesn't spawn in at all and enters a weird buggy state where he stays in your crew but only until you talk to him again outside of the ship
- After finishing the monastery quest and killing whoever was in charge there, the area doesn't unlock at all. I spent 30 minutes walking aimlessly until I happened on the tiny little exit that was still open.
- If your game runs too long, you cannot save anymore. Autosaves also stop happening. Have fun recovering hours upon hours of your game if you picked up after leaving it on overnight.
Recent Activity
164 hrs on record
last played on Nov 22
169 hrs on record
last played on Nov 22
1.8 hrs on record
last played on Nov 9